The Korea Herald: Should pornography be censored?

Pornography Censorship(Source)

I make a brief appearance in the Korea Herald today, in an article by John Power on the recent government crackdown on pornography. With his permission, here are all of his original questions and my replies, with some links for further reading:

1. Do you foresee the Korean public becoming increasingly unhappy with the heavy censorship of pornography and other sexual content in the short term? Or do you think a largely conservative Korean public will remain happy with the status quo?

In all my 12 years in Korea, ordinary Koreans have loudly and consistently complained of being treated like children by censors. But the censorship of movies has been considerably relaxed in recent years (recall that the Korean Supreme Court overturned a ban on Shortbus for instance), and even the Ministry of Gender Equality and Family has begun to acknowledge its own excesses with music videos. So this latest crackdown actually goes against recent trends, and I expect it to face a lot of opposition.

2. Often, censorship is justified to protect young people. Do you think there is a feasible way of protecting youth, while not controlling what adults wish to see?

Frankly I don’t, but this is a dilemma faced by every democracy. Most, however, don’t resort to the draconian restrictions imposed by the Korean government, yet somehow have equal or lower rates of sex crimes by and/or against minors nonetheless.

(“Because I’m a man / 남자기 때문에.” For English subtitles, click on “captions”)

3. A local site pornography site called Soranet had 600,000 subscribers before it was shut down in 2004, showing the widespread nature of its consumption. Do you think the government is fighting a losing battle in trying to ban such material?

If nothing else, banned sites will remain available via proxy servers, but I’m sure young, tech-savy Koreans won’t need to resort to using those. With the proviso that of course the government should continue to monitor the pornography industry as a whole, to prevent exploitation and the use of minors, you have to question the government’s zeal in attacking an otherwise victimless activity, and which there is clearly a huge demand for. Surely the time and resources could be better spent? Perhaps on more up-to-date and effective sex-education, so people could better judge the supposed harmful effects of pornography for themselves?

4. What do you think is the true motivation for censorship of adult content in Korea? Or, put another way, do you think there are sometimes hidden agendas at play?

As someone who notoriously devoted Seoul to God as mayor, and who believes that (re)criminalizing abortion is an effective method of raising the birth rate, clearly Lee Myung-bak’s conservative and religious beliefs are playing a big role here. That aside, blaming pornography for sex crimes, and censoring it on that basis, is also an easy way for the ruling party to appear to be doing something to address public concerns during its candidate’s presidential election campaign, yet without doing anything about their real causes whatsoever.

Ga-in's BEG Concert Teaser(Source)

5. Do you think there are double standards at play in the how and what content is restricted?

If we’re talking specifically about pornography, then no. As for K-pop however, both fans’ widespread perceptions and the empirical evidence suggests that female entertainers are disproportionately censored, often for things that make entertainers are allowed to do scotfree. In particular, whenever female entertainers present themselves as sexual subjects rather than just objects for the male gaze, then the ironically-named Ministry of Gender Equality and Family can be expected to come down hard on them. A good recent case of this is the ban placed on Ga-in’s Bloom, a rare song about sexual awakening from a woman’s perspective, whereas the Ministry had no problem with the gratuitous skin shots in Hyuna’s Ice Cream.

What do you think?

7 thoughts on “The Korea Herald: Should pornography be censored?

  1. The US is even more schizophrenic about this than Korea, and while my home, Canada, is nice and tolerant, an undercurrent of half-feigned madness does seep through the cracks every now and then.

    We all know this is empty posturing. This society is saturated with sex, graphic images of sex and sexual exploitation. Pornography is, if it’s a crime, the least of a vast series of social offences. Not a single person in Korea with prohibitionist tendencies on any subject of any kind isn’t also a hypocrite of the the highest possible order.

    K-Pop is all about exporting the sexy young nothings of Korea’s blooming youth; there’s no other element to it worth reporting on. Men and women here now get plastic surgery done on industrial scales in order to advance in sexual and social worth, all measured by sexual attractiveness. Norebangs and room salons are doing booming business, and clubs have innumerable paid attendees to keep the Cool Factor high. Prostitution is a national sport.

    And censors for LMB’s government are going to target porn? It’s the the most opportunistic stab in the dark I’ve ever heard of.

    • “while my home, Canada, is nice and tolerant, an undercurrent of half-feigned madness does seep through the cracks every now and then”

      Craig, you should read Canada’s pornography laws then. Our home country is nice and tolerant because it doesn’t bother to enforce them in these days when it would be impossible anyways, but back in the days of off-line porn it did, and enforced regulations at both the national and provincial levels. Do you not remember Saskatchewan banning the film Exit to Eden? Of course these days they can barely do anything about child porn but if a government agency wanted to they could apply these laws selectively and arbitrarily. Did you know that in Canada – note, not Korea, Canada – there already is a law that makes porn in which adults are depicted as minors illegal? Thus, if your wife dressed up as a school cheerleader and you filmed her having sex with you, you would be in possession of and guilty of making illegal material, at least according to the letter of the law.

      Back in the early 90s when off-line porn still got imported into Canada my classmate got an intern position at the BC Attorney General’s office doing, of all things, porn censorship. He said that all sorts of stuff like S&M and watersports and “unconventional porn” that was legal in the US got blocked or put aside for review.

      • Yes, exactly. Korea has no monopoly on arbitrary and selective enforcement of the law. It’s amazing how human nature and the corruption of goals seems to be so universal. This is why I think LMB’s move here was really just for show. Nobody can take it seriously.

  2. Where the largest market is, also seems to be where the largest push to censor it exists. Ironic, to say the least. Let them have it. Porn has been keeping sexless marriages together for centuries! If you don’t believe me, look up the documentary series, “The History of Pornography.”

  3. Pingback: Korea Puts the “No” in Porno | Kimchibytes

  4. Pingback: Korea Puts the “No” in Porno. | Kimchibytes

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s