Korean Gender Reader

elton-john-drugs-quoteSource: id-iom.

Sorry for the delay: although I’d like to provide a much more professional-sounding excuse, the reality is that my toddler’s constant temper tantrums over the last two days have completely ruined my blogging plans for this week!

1. Joo Ji-hoon Drug Scandal

My personal choice for the most interesting story last week. In brief:

In the latest drug bust of entertainers, police booked popular film star Ju Ji-hun, 27, on suspicion of drug use and arrest warrants were sought for actress Yun Seol-hee, 28, and model Ye Hak-young, 26, for alleged smuggling ecstasy tablets and ketamine into the country from Japan. Two other residents were booked on similar suspicions.

“Besides the suspects on the list we have secured, there are likely more, given the amount of drugs smuggled. Further investigations are unavoidable,” an officer of the Seoul Metropolitan Policy Agency said (Korea Times).

Why I found it so interesting, and why it’s notable in a feminist sense, is because of how the huge disparities between Western and Korean celebrity culture may play out here. Very broadly speaking, Westerners usually tolerate – nay, encourage –  debauchery on the part of their idols, but Koreans are the polar opposite, usually demanding of celebrities standards of behavior and conduct much stricter than they do of themselves. Throw sexual double-standards and many especially young actresses frequently playing “sweet and innocent” roles into the mix too, then many female celebrities in particular have faced heavy public opprobrium once they have been revealed to be, say, merely human.

Yoon eun hye the temptressHence my first thought that the female celebrities involved in this scandal might get the most flak for it, but as Joo Ji-hoon (주지훈) is so much better known than them then so far most attention has been on him instead. Naturally, this story is all over the K-pop blogs, but DramaBeans provides the best coverage: see here, here and then here for all the details in chronological order, to which I’d add the surprising news that so far he hasn’t given the tearful apology that is de rigueur for these situations, and instead is – shock! horror! – unrepentant.

(Right: Does the blame ultimately lie with Yoon Eun-hye? Source)

2. I’ve Got You Under My Skin

Previous restrictions on nudity, sex, and swearing in the media are rapidly being lifted in Korea (see #1 here), but that doesn’t mean that all the individuals and institutions involved are liberalizing things at the same speed, nor, indeed, that they’re even on the same page. As I explain in the bottom of this post:

…aside from the government’s push for a  “real name” internet system of course, one other notable censorship issue is the Youth Protection Committee’s (of the Ministry for Health, Welfare and Family Affairs; see #4 here) recent banning of music group TVXQ’s latest songs from being played on TV and the radio because of “lewd content” (see here also). But one might ask what exactly the point was considering the album has already been out for six months though!

And blogger Gord Sellar has written an excellent post on the supreme irony of this:

…The idea that a censor who cannot speak English well enough to understand the nuances of what’s being said is interesting.

But then again, there’s also the nuances of what’s being heard. After all, I can say, “Ha, that censor doesn’t know enough English to know that it means, “I’ve got you on my mind,” or, “You’ve affected me emotionally in such a way that I cannot shake this effect you have on me.” But the censor’s grasp of English is…

Well, there’s the question. The Ministry for Health, Welfare and Family Affairs certainly doesn’t seem to know what the phrase means in English — though it’s well-documented, is present in popular culture, and absolutely innocuous in an English speaking context. (Even the stuff about “… deep down in the heart of me, so deep inside, that you’re really a part of me…” is tame enough to have been on mainstream TV back when sexual content was not broadcast in the States.)

See here for the rest.

3. More Female Toilets to be Built in Seoul

By coincidence, I heard on the Guardian Daily podcast last year about recent changes to laws in the UK requiring all new buildings to have female toilets double the size of those provided for men, and as a guy I had no idea of just how impractical and inconvenient and still steeped in a Victorian architectural mentality many are there, ultimately with big impacts on women with children in particular (and in turn, families), although as a father now I have much the same problems myself, and can certainly empathize. See here, here, here for more information on that UK case, but most of the problems mentioned would be universal,  and so provide some good context for the following news about the Seoul City Government, which will:

…increase the number of women’s toilets to close to that of their male counterparts. Currently, there are 42,348 male toilets compared to only 34,649 toilets for females. It will build 3,100 more this year and 3,800 next year (Korea Times).

A curious disparity. Regardless, and even if you’re a guy and/or not interested in such matters, at the very least more and bigger female toilets will mean less waiting for your partner, as someone on the podcast I heard mentioned.

Another, somewhat misguided initiative also mentioned in that report is to provide many slightly larger female-only car-parking spaces, the logic presumably being that women are worse drivers and so need more space to maneuver. Admittedly I don’t drive myself, but I’m pretty confident that any car-insurance salesperson can confirm that that is complete bullshit (women actually have less accidents than men), and so this idea reflects the prejudices of the city councilors more than anything else.

Update: See KoreaBeat here for more details.

4. Gwangju Female High School Students Stripped as Punishment

For the details, see Brian in Jeollanam-do here. One minor thing that he forgot to mention in that post is that it occurred at an all-girl high school, but which is not to say that that condones the punishment in any way

Also occurring at a high school, it was reported by the Korea Times that four male teachers are to receive punishment for sexually harassing female interns. Unfortunately, given a history of teachers getting off lightly for far worse offenses, such as one being given only a six-month sentence for sex with an 11 year-old (see #9 here), then…let’s just say I have my doubts as to how effective their ultimate “punishment” will be.

5. Han Chae-young Models Men’s Clothes

han-chae-young-rogatis-한채영-로가디스As allkpop reports, Rogatis (로가디스), a Korean menswear company, has chosen actress Han Chae-young (한채영), as their next model for their latest line of mens clothing (right, source). Not that significant perhaps, but it immediately brought to mind Danish clothing company JBS’s notorious underwear advertisements from last year, which featured virtually naked (naturally) women in men’s underwear, and which ultimately got…er…pulled (see here and here for more on those, but which are probably NSFW).

Now, I’m not going to feign outrage at those, nor at the notion of using women to model men’s clothes in itself, although personally I found the ones with nurses and so forth actually sniffing the underwear (and savoring the smell) to be very unrealistic more of a turn-off than anything else. But I’m curious as to readers’ opinions on the Rogatis advertisements specifically, as although they’re certainly still quite risqué (see more examples here), most of the complaints against those by JSB focused less on the women’s nudity as their explicit subservience in them, which clearly doesn’t apply here.

So, does it work? It it still objectionable in any way? Why, why not?

6. Korea’s Lost Generation

First becoming involved in Korean sociology via the huge differences in living arrangements for 20-somethings between Korea and Western countries, then I’ve long been interested in the various financial barriers that prevented Korean twenty-somethings from leaving home, and without which it’s no exaggeration to say a veritable revolution in Korean sexuality would occur. Indeed, the situation of today, rife with double-standards and open secrets and all, is not at all dissimilar to that of Western countries before huge expansions in university enrollments in the 1960s and 1970s, but until a similar Korean generation of cohabitants that no longer feels a need to hide things emerges from that, then it will continue to be women especially that suffer the most from sexual matters not being out in the open, either physically or by placing feminine virginity and “modesty” on a pedestal.

In my most recent posts on the subject then (here, here, and here), excessive student loan interest rates and rising univeristy fees have emerged as the biggest of those financial burdens, and in many ways what is occurring in Korea today parallels what occurred when I was a student myself in New Zealand in the mid-1990s. I didn’t, however, have this to contend with also:

As a candidate, President Lee Myung-bak promised to slash school fees by 50 percent and create 600,000 jobs annually. He did neither….

….It’s true President Lee had made these pledges before he knew the world would fall to what he has dubbed the “unprecedented” economic crisis. But there are not many governments trying to get out of this crisis by cutting initial salaries of college graduates, and telling them to remain content with internships, as the Lee administration does now.

President Lee called for the new entrants into labor markets, who probably constitute the best-educated generation of all, to “lower their sights and start humbly.” This could pass as advice among individuals but hardly a sermon coming from a responsible official ― much less the head of state ― to the fresh workforce that will shoulder the nation’s future.

By all means much recent criticism about the Korea Times is deserved (see here and here), but the editorial that that is from may prove remarkably prescient: at the very least, telling a whole swath of young people to STFU and be content with working in Family Mart for what should be the most productive and exciting part of their lives will accentuate their disengagement with the political process.

7. Birth, Death and Divorce in Korea

A swathe of statistics on each have been published recently:  for links and analysis on the former two especially, see Matt at Gusts of Popular Feeling here, and for the latter see Brian in Jelloanamdo here.

Meanwhile, if you’re futher interested in Korean demographics, particularly similarities and differences in family structures between Korea, the US, and Japan,  then you’ll probably like this series of mine on the subject also.

8. Korea’s Lack of Rape Kits: A Comparison to the U.S.

As someone who gets plagiarized himself on a regular basis, then normally I’d be very reluctant to cut and paste a post by KoreaBeat in its entirety, but in this case I think I can make a rare exception:

Nicholas Kristof wrote in [the] New York Times about the problem of severely backlogged rape kits in the United States, putting me in mind of how they are often never even collected in Korea.

And the latter, a translation of a lengthy article on the subject, should be required reading for everyone reading this blog!

If you reside in South Korea, you can donate via wire transfer: Turnbull James Edward (Kookmin Bank/국민은행, 563401-01-214324)

6 thoughts on “Korean Gender Reader

  1. It’s significant I think that it was a female teacher who administered the punishment, but from the anecdotal evidence I saw on Dave’s, it seems that there are plenty of male teachers at all girls’ high schools, so it’s not like the punishment occurred in a same-sex vacuum.

    This topic came up among some people I met over the weekend. We all agree it’s way over the line, and that it’s ridiculous to start in on how dangerous native speaker teachers might be to students when there’s stuff like this going on. But, this type of punishment doesn’t seem to be that unusual or foreign. Remember the story about the Seoul daycare center that got in some trouble for putting the children outside naked?
    I remember others saying that this was a traditional type of punishment. And a woman I met this weekend said she saw it administered to a middle school boy in her old neighborhood. Koreans are more comfortable with nudity, which—not that this at all justifies it—just reinforces that this probably wasn’t sexual in nature, but just some type of bizarre type of humiliation. Of course, the teacher will probably get a warning or something, and then all will be forgotten on the Gwangju teacher front until one of us is photographed dancing with a Korean woman.


  2. James,

    I like the shorter posts, partly because I hope that will also mean more frequent posting?

    But the shorter posts are also easier for retardos like me to digest, so that’s another good thing. ;-)

    James, 10:06pm: Just in case anyone is confused, Charles wrote that when I had the following message after topic #5 in the first version of this post:

    *And although only half-finished, I thought I’d provide half a post rather than postponing this already late post still further, and I’ll provide the second half tomorrow night. Come to think of it though, 5 stories at a time may well be more digestible than the 14 or so at once I usually provide? Please let me know which format you prefer in the comments, and I’ll see what I can do)


  3. Sorry to wander off-topic, but in case you haven’t seen it already, you might check out Dove Evolution at Youtube. A bare-faced Western model is transformed into a billboard image. Even after hours of work by stylists, her face still gets edited, including eye enlargement.


  4. the dove thing is a couple of years old, but definitely worth a look . . .
    Re: the Bathroom Problem. . . I’m curious, how are they counting bathrooms? Is it toilets vs. toilets, toilets vs. urinals, total stalls? I’m not surprised to find that there are more male bathrooms, and have always found that Korea, like most nations, is still remarkably unequal in the distribution of actual useable fascilities. When bathrooms for men and women are of equivalent size, there are still more opportunities for men because urinals use relatively less space than a full stall with toilet, and so what seems like an equitable distribution is often far from it. Just here at work, the men’s bathroom has the same two stalls as the womens, but either two or three urinals as well (hmm, shall I sneak in to confirm?) which means that effectively twice as many men can (echem) get down to business in the same span of time. Other places will have a men’s stall, women’s stall, and urinal, with the end result being the same – plus giving us the dubious joy of walking past a peeing man on our way to the stall. And then men have the gall to complain about how long we take in the ladies room!!!
    Re: Women modeling men’s cloths – BUT DAMMIT! This should be *MY* chance to have a little visual gratification! You guys can find ads featuring stripped down ladies anywhere you like, and this company is going to deprive me of yet another opportunity for an oiled up manly figure to ignore on my way to work. Sad, sad, sad, so very sad. Unfair, I call it.


    1. I only had #6, 7, & 8 to add in the end, but with: 4 hours sleep (again); my 3 year-old daughter kicking me in the eye earlier (and knocking a contact lens out) because for some reason she’d rather have her mother put her to sleep tonight (closest I’ve ever come to hitting her so far…my daughter that is, not my wife; no, I’ve never hit her either…sigh, sleep deprivation…I’d better shut up); my KT piece to write; and me just discovering I’ve got to work at a part-time job tomorrow also when I expected the day off, then a coherent fuller reply will have to wait a little sorry!


      1. Hell…if I wasn’t really tired and was just making excuses in my last comment, then I certainly did a good impression of it!

        Brian–Thanks for the extra context. I’m also (now) inclined to think that the punishment wasn’t at all sexual really, even without mentioning Koreans’ more relaxed attitudes to nudity. I probably made it sound more significant than it was in the post.

        Charles–I’ll bear that in mind. I don’t think I can really break up the weekly Feminist Reader on a regular basis…hell, getting it out on a regular basis at all is a mission…but I am slowly but surely working towards 5 posts a week, albeit not one a day M-F like planned (very few people read on weekends, so why bother?). But if it makes you feel better, that is my goal anyway.

        While we’re on the topic, you may have noticed that I have only 3 posts up on the main page now – less of a mass to wade through (and load), and *cough* makes people more likely to click through to older posts – and my goal is to always have at least one of those (well, usually exactly one, and reluctantly!) a “serious” post.

        Sonagi–Thanks again, and I will once I have the chance.

        Gomushin Girl–I hear you, and the last problem you mention with small bathrooms works both ways: I don’t particularly like peeing in front of other men, let alone women, and I always wonder how dates might go if both happened to bump into each other like that before they realized that one should probably wait for the other…not very well I imagine.

        I often hear that small country, small buildings hastily thrown up are the main reason for shared bathrooms and/or lack of urinals being hidden away, and that’s certainly true, but I still find all too many bathrooms in new buildings with exactly the same problem. The worst example I know is a brand new cinema in Jangsan, here in Busan, which has an open door (well, entranceway: there’s no door) to the guy’s toilet and a urinal literally 10 cm away from that. The hallway outside would be very busy most times, and so would mean some people passing the door would literally be about a foot/30cm-ish away from a guy pissing. And this in an otherwise nice, modern cinema, built in 2006 I think.

        Re: the ad. I’m not so sure that you’re being deprived of an oiled up manly figure sorry: it tends to leave unsightly marks on the clothes.


Leave a Reply to Brian Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s